Home » Latest News » Indigenous Recruitment and Training
Latest News

Indigenous Recruitment and Training

The most progressive companies are taking a long-term view, concludes a study from the Centre for Social Responsibility in Mining (CSRM).

‘Indigenous employment in the Australian minerals industry’ was a two-year study aimed at assisting companies and operations to improve their capacity to attract, retain and develop Indigenous employees.Sponsored by Rio Tinto, the project was conducted under the auspices of the Minerals Council of Australia’s Social Policy Taskforce.

THE CHANGING LANDSCAPE

Within the minerals sector there is an emerging body of good practice in Indigenous employment and recruitment. The most progressive mining companies are taking a long-term view and, in addition to providing employment opportunities, are participating in initiatives to address the root causes of Indigenous socio-economic disadvantage – poor education, poor health and poverty.

A key business driver is the recognition by mining companies that robust relationships with Indigenous people based on recognition, respect, trust and honouring commitments are fundamental to maintaining the industry’s ‘social licence to operate’ and ensuring long-term access to land and new resources.

Other factors driving the increased focus by companies on Indigenous employment and addressing socio- economic disadvantage include social and demographic changes in the regions of Australia where mining occurs, particularly the projected Indigenous population growth, and continuing skills shortages in remote and regional areas.

OBSTACLES TO EMPLOYMENT

Factors that can make it difficult for Indigenous people to obtain work in the minerals industry include:

  • Ølack of education and relevant training
  • Ølack of exposure to the mainstream workforce, the ‘industrial culture’ of the mining industry and the expectations of employers
  • Øgeographical isolation
  • Øthe challenges involved in balancing family and community obligations with the demands of full-time work
  • Øpoor health and difficulties in complying with drug and alcohol testing regimes.

For mining companies wishing to employ more Indigenous people the obstacles include:

  • Øthe lack of a ‘job-ready’ labour pool
  • Øinsufficient appreciation of how socio-economic disadvantage impacts on the recruitment and retention of Indigenous employees.

THE PEOPLE FACTOR

First and foremost, achieving sustainable improvements in Indigenous employment requires organisational commitment. Companies with successful Indigenous employment strategies are characterised by:

  • Øan executive leadership team that has publicly committed to improving Indigenous employment outcomes and backs this commitment by providing adequate financial and human resources
  • Øa commitment to the development of honest and transparent relationships with Indigenous communities
  • Øcorporate champions who ‘go the extra mile’ in supporting Indigenous employees and who have influence with the operation’s management team to ensure that Indigenous employment issues remain on the corporate agenda
  • Øsuitably qualified, skilled, informed and committed personnel in training and liaison positions, who are respected by the local Indigenous community.

RECRUITMENT STRATEGIES

Traditional HR systems and processes can present barriers for Indigenous people seeking to enter the mainstream workforce. Leading companies have developed a range of strategies to assist Indigenous people overcome these barriers. These include:

  • Øfocusing more on face-to-face rather than written communication with potential applicants
  • Øusing selection centre workshops to identify individual skills and abilities
  • Øadopting flexible strategies to manage problems with drug and alcohol use
  • Ødeveloping work readiness programs that prepare Indigenous people for the transition into the mainstream workforce
  • Øprovision of cultural awareness training for all recruits, Indigenous and non-Indigenous, as part of the induction process.

RETENTION STRATEGIES

While considerable effort has been put into developing new approaches to Indigenous recruitment, relatively little has been done in the way of developing specific retention strategies for Indigenous employees. Indigenous employees face particular challenges in balancing work and family commitments and making the transition to a new organisational and cultural environment. For employees of fly-in, fly-out operations, an added pressure is the need to spend extended periods away from home.

Strategies for increasing retention include:

  • Øprovision of ongoing mentoring and support
  • Ømore flexible work rosters
  • Øprovision of career development opportunities > provision of family support> addressing racism in the workforce.

CONTRACTOR ISSUES

All the sites visited for the study made substantial use of contractors including, in some cases, contracting out the mining operation. Some of the contracting companies have invested substantial resources in developing and maintaining an Indigenous workforce.

Some relevant issues are:

  • ØThe cost associated with training Indigenous people and their limited productivity during training appears not to be factored into mining company tendering systems.
  • ØMining company tendering systems do not necessarily consider Indigenous employment in their tender evaluation system weightings.
  • ØCooperative efforts between mining companies and contractors will be required to overcome these barriers and deliver equitable systems for managing Indigenous employment initiatives.

RESOURCES FOR PRACTITIONERS

  • ØHaving robust management systems in place makes it much easier for operations to monitor the effectiveness of their employment initiatives and ensure that there is appropriate follow-up. Most of the sites that were visited for this study operated without the benefit of such a system. ?To assist operations to improve their management processes we have developed two tools:
  • Øthe Organisational Maturity Chart, which enables ?practitioners and company personnel to evaluate the level of maturity of their Indigenous employment policies and practices and identify the steps that can be taken to improve performance
  • Øthe Indigenous Employment Evaluation Tool (published separately), which provides a model for operations to use in developing their own Indigenous employment management systems.

CONCLUSION

The public commitment by the minerals industry to increasing Indigenous workforce participation has the potential to deliver better socio-economic outcomes for those Indigenous communities located in or near regions where there is large-scale mining. The knowledge and good practice examples shared in this report should assist the industry to translate its commitments to Indigenous communities into improved performance on the ground.

 

Rio Tinto Iron Ore (RTIO) Indigenous Retention Project

In recent years, the Australian mining industry has proactively increased the representation of Indigenous employees within their workforce. However, although the industry has had some success in recruiting Indigenous employees, retaining these employees has emerged as a major challenge.

The provision of Aboriginal employment and training opportunities form part of current agreements made between RTIO and Aboriginal parties in the Pilbara, and also relate to commitments made by Rio Tinto to broader corporate social responsibility and sustainable development principles.

This project aims Identify factors that contribute to voluntary turnover amongst Aboriginal people employed at RTIO operations in the Pilbara Region of North West Australia. The project includes a survey of former employees of RTIO operations, as well as focus groups with current employees. The survey will identify variations in employment and obtained information about working conditions, employment outcomes, and suggestions for RTIO to improve retention of their Indigenous employees.

The study has four main objectives:

  • ØTo support the development of strategies for improving the retention of Aboriginal employees at RTIO operations
  • ØTo collect research data that will assist in monitoring employment outcomes
  • ØTo assist RTIO to develop improved exit interviewing and follow-up procedures
  • ØTo identify former Aboriginal employees who may wish to return to RTIO.

This project will provide valuable research data on long-term employment outcomes for Aboriginal people who have worked at RTIO. The findings will also have broader relevance to both the Rio Group and the mining industry.

 

Benefits Of The Partnership Approach

While the partnership approach places clear obligations on government, industry partners and Indigenous communities to improve socio-economic outcomes for Indigenous people, it also offers potential benefits to all parties.

GOVERNMENT

As employers, mining companies are a potential source of new jobs for Indigenous people. Especially in remote areas where there are few business alternatives, they may be the only large-scale employers. Since the alternative to work for many people is welfare dependency, there are sound financial and policy reasons for governments to promote partnerships with industry as a means of getting people into the mainstream workforce and becoming taxpayers.

Mining companies are also experienced in sourcing education and training opportunities for their employees. Apart from public sector organisations, only large corporations have the resources to source and deliver targeted education and training programs. Again, from a policy perspective, it is clearly an advantage to government to be able to link education and training with employment opportunities in the local area.

INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES

From the perspective of Indigenous communities, the partnership approach opens up the possibility of developing prosperous communities that will survive beyond the life of the mines. First, partnering with mining companies gives Indigenous people the opportunity to participate in the mainstream workforce. Access to paid work is a fundamental prerequisite for participation in the mainstream economy. Second, access to training and education is essential if Indigenous people are to develop the necessary skills to participate in that economy.

Access to education, training and employment is the key to building sustainable Indigenous communities. Mining companies have a critical role to play in capacity building because they can provide training, not just for operational roles, but in the areas of leadership training, and the development of management and governance skills. If Indigenous people are to live in prosperous and sustainable communities, it is essential for them to develop leadership and management skills, which are essential competencies of viable communities.

The other huge advantage of the partnerships approach for Indigenous people is that it gives them a voice in planning for the future. Instead of being the passive recipients of welfare or educational and training programs that others have deemed beneficial to them, Indigenous people become partners in decision- making processes that affect their future. Without ‘buy in’ from local community members, efforts to improve the socio-economic conditions in Indigenous communities are unlikely to be successful.

Benefits for the minerals industry

There are sound business reasons for mining companies to partner with Indigenous communities and government to deliver better employment outcomes for Indigenous people. In the case of individual companies, these relate particularly to enabling land access and the possibility of developing a regional workforce to sustain company operations into the future. At the industry level, there are also benefits in terms of enhancing the reputation of the industry in the eyes of government and local communities.

REGIONAL WORKFORCE

Fostering a partnership approach and creating employment opportunities for Indigenous people can be regarded as an investment in the creation of a skilled regional workforce that will provide the labour for the mines of the future. The majority of Australia’s mining operations are in remote and rural areas. Accessing skilled staff in these locations has always been difficult for mining companies and enormous amounts of money have been spent on developing expensive town infrastructure and services to support their operations. More recently, there has been a trend towards fly-in fly- out (FIFO) operations, but these, too, have a number of disadvantages for companies.

Historically, these significant investments have been made without consideration for the sustainability of the regional economy beyond the life of the mine and without considering local Indigenous people as a potential labour force for the operation. Increasingly, however, companies are coming to see that there are benefits to their operations in building regional capacity. By supporting and promoting education, training and other local initiatives that increase the skills base of Indigenous communities, companies are contributing to the development of a skilled local workforce and a prosperous local economy.

INDUSTRY REPUTATION

Commitment to a partnerships approach is a way of improving the reputation of the minerals industry globally. Companies that form successful partnerships with government and Indigenous communities are likely to find that their reputations are enhanced beyond the boundaries of Australia. Successful partnerships send a signal that the company has the credentials for negotiating fairly and successfully with Indigenous communities in other parts of the world.

Commitment to sustainable development is also likely to improve the image and reputation of the minerals industry. In particular, it connects the minerals industry with major social changes that are occurring elsewhere in the world, especially those surrounding social responsibility and Indigenous rights. This places the industry in a position to argue for its causes, while respecting the rights of others.

Potentially, there are enormous benefits?to Indigenous communities, government and mining companies alike in achieving better employment outcomes. The remainder of this report documents a range of processes, procedures and good practice case studies to enable mining companies to participate actively in this commitment to improving Indigenous employment outcomes.

EDUCATION

Perhaps the greatest obstacle to increasing Indigenous workforce participation rates is poor education levels. Most Indigenous people living close to the mining operations in this study come from communities that have been marginalised from the mainstream social and economic institutions. As a result, most have received little formal education and lack the basic literacy and numeracy skills to perform tasks that most people take for granted-reading the positions vacant section of a newspaper to look for jobs, getting a driver’s license, preparing a résumé, or filling out a standard job application form.

Companies in this study have adopted a two-pronged approach to dealing with these problems. First, they have adapted their standard HR recruiting practices to take into account these skills differences. These issues are discussed in detail in the sections of this report dealing with recruitment, retention and staff development strategies. Second, they have taken a longer term view and committed to an investment in the future of local communities, by partnering with government and local community members to improve education outcomes in local schools. One initiative showing great promise is the Western Cape College.

IMPLICATIONS FOR EMPLOYERS

The key implication for employers who are looking to include more Indigenous people at their operations is that, because of major education, health and social problems, there is only a limited pool of Indigenous people who are ‘work-ready’, that is who have the necessary job experience and skills to move directly into the workforce. In several remote locations there are signs that the majority of work-ready people have already been recruited and some operations are having difficulty in meeting their Indigenous employment targets. Therefore, to achieve sustained improvement in Indigenous employment outcomes, mining companies need to:

  • ØFocus recruitment efforts on Indigenous people who may not have participated previously in the mainstream workforce. As we discuss in the following section on recruitment, some mining companies are already doing some very good work in this area. In particular, they are investing in a range of work readiness or prevocational schemes to prepare Indigenous employees for the workforce
  • ØConsider re-employing Indigenous people who have worked at the operation previously, but who did not complete training programs or resigned from their jobs. There are indications that some Indigenous people come and go from the workforce several times before settling more permanently into a job. Therefore flexible HR systems and working arrangements that enable them to acclimatise gradually to the demands of the workforce should be considered.
  • ØReconsider the educational standards that are set for particular entry level positions. There may be a case for redefining the selection criteria for Indigenous applicants, just to get them into the workforce
  • ØEngage with the ‘bigger picture’ issues, such as providing education and training for school children. The Western Cape College story is an example of investment in a longer-term strategy to create job-ready people
  • ØEngage with partners to address the larger socio- economic issues, such as the provision of health services, and drug and alcohol programs. The purpose of the partnership approach is to share commitments and responsibilities between partners. It is not the role of the minerals industry alone to solve Indigenous health and social problems. It is their responsibility, however, to find more effective ways of working with government and local communities on these issues. By aiding in the development of new ideas, offering skills and contributing to the funding of initiatives, the industry will play a major role in the development of sustainable Indigenous communities

RECRUITMENT

Having identified the ‘big picture’ items that influence the success of strategies to increase Indigenous participation rates in the work force, in this section we move to a discussion of specific strategies that companies are implementing to recruit more Indigenous employees. We found that mainstream recruitment practices are not always appropriate for Indigenous people and that leading companies have adapted their recruiting programs to meet the needs of Indigenous people.

We begin this section with a discussion of standard recruitment processes, and why they are inappropriate for many Indigenous people. We then provide examples of good practice recruitment strategies that are operating at some of the sites we visited. Table 7 summarises the differences between the mainstream approach and good practice Indigenous recruitment processes.

Good Practice Indigenous Recruitment Processes

Most of the participating sites in this study have recognised the limitations in using standard recruitment systems to recruit Indigenous employees. Their response has been to adapt existing practices and procedures to meet the needs of Indigenous employees. In this section we discuss the various ways in which operations have changed their practices, by adopting a ‘pull’ rather than a ‘push’ strategy.

ADVERTISING THE VACANCY

The first stage of the recruitment process is normally to advertise the vacancy. Operations in this study that have been successful in attracting Indigenous applicants for job vacancies tend to adopt a more proactive approach to Indigenous recruitment. In particular, they recognise that different approaches may be needed for remote areas and rural or regional centres.

In remote areas, instead of assuming that suitable applicants will read newspaper advertisements or have access to company websites, company personnel visit local communities personally to spread the word that the local operation is looking for employees. Typically, staff members travel to the local community, hand out copies of the advertisement, post the notice on the local bulletin board and then talk to individuals or their families about the vacancy. This approach enables them to identify new recruits and also to maintain contact with people who may have applied unsuccessfully for jobs in the past, but are now ready to reapply, or who have previously worked for the company and may be interested in returning to the site.

While most operations use company staff members to visit communities to advertise job vacancies, one operation in this study uses the local Land Council to contact potential employees. In this case, the Land Council has a group of people working specifically on developing opportunities for Indigenous employment. Since the Land Council already has established relationships with the local Indigenous community, the company prefers to use their expertise to identify potential employees. This approach also enables the company to build its relationship with the Land Council.

In the case of small Indigenous communities in remote areas, word of mouth is the most popular method of advertising vacancies. Indigenous employees currently working at a site will put forward the names of people from their community that they know are looking for work. Other successful methods include the distribution of flyers and broadcasting on local Aboriginal radio stations to activate the local grapevine (Archer & Widdeson, 2002).

For rural and regional centres, job vacancies are usually advertised via mainstream methods; namely, newspaper and radio advertisements. Many regional centres have their own employment agencies with links into the local Indigenous communities. Typically, when operations are looking for new employees, they contact local service providers to ask them to spread the word about job vacancies through their Indigenous networks. Company employees in the HR and / or community teams who have good local knowledge and relationships with Indigenous people may also get in touch with potential recruits they know who may be interested in a position.

THE APPLICATION PROCESS

The next stage in the recruitment process is the application stage. The most important way an operation can increase the chances of Indigenous people making it through the application stage is to help them to improve the quality of their applications. This is best achieved by providing Indigenous applicants with assistance to complete the application forms and develop résumés.

In large remote regions the application stage is conducted at the same time as the advertisement stage or during a follow up visit. Company personnel provide potential recruits with assistance to complete the application forms and write résumés. Where an agent is used such as a Land Council, Land Council employees provide this assistance. In rural and regional centres, employment agencies provide any support required to complete applications and write résumés.

THE SELECTION PROCESS

The fourth stage of the recruitment process, the selection stage, is the one that differs most from standard recruitment practice. While the same screening checks are conducted, the way that the information is provided to Indigenous applicants is somewhat different. The actual process for all applicants involves:

  • Øshort listing the applicants
  • Øpsychometric testing
  • Ødrug and alcohol testing
  • Øselection centre workshops
  • Øselecting the right person
  • Ømaking the offer of appointment.

SHORT LISTING THE APPLICANTS

In some of the large remote regions a major part of this process is completed during the community visits described previously. Applicants who apply during community visits generally require some further scrutiny, so their applications and résumés are assessed and reference checks conducted in the usual manner by the employer. A common practice is to informally access local knowledge about applicants as a more useful way of gaining an accurate impression of the applicant’s abilities than the standard telephone interview. This process of assessing application forms and résumés, conducting reference checks and conducting informal checks by talking to local people about the capabilities of the applicant is most generally adopted in rural and regional centres.

PSYCHOMETRIC TESTING

In conjunction with the interview process, sites routinely conduct a series of screening tests; psychometric tests, a medical check, alcohol and drug testing and, in some cases, a security check. These present a major hurdle for some Indigenous people and are one of the chief reasons for failing to make it through the selection process.

The issue of psychometric testing is a problematic one. Psychometric testing falls into three main types: ability testing, aptitude testing and personality questionnaires. Ability tests measure a person’s potential, for instance to learn the skills needed for a new job or to cope with the demands of a training course. Aptitude tests are tests of attainment, designed to assess specifically what people have learned. Aptitude tests are usually job related; for example, they may test driving ability or typing skills. Personality tests are usually carried out to assess a person’s ability to fit in with a given work environment.

Most minerals operations use some form of psychometric testing when recruiting. However, most of the operations in this study did not use them for Indigenous applicants because they found that many Indigenous applicants perform poorly in these tests. The problem with psychometric testing is that results are easily misinterpreted and subject to cultural bias. First, experienced professionals are needed to administer the tests and interpret the results. Second, psychometric questionnaires cannot be used in isolation – their output must be interpreted in the light of a number of factors such as the individual’s past experience, skills and future goals. Third, and most importantly, factors other than the characteristic or ability being measured can influence the results; for example, cultural background, type of education or familiarity with testing procedures.

The issue of cultural bias is the reason why most of the sites in this study do not generally use psychometric testing for Indigenous employees. However, psychometric testing can be a useful tool in assessing the capabilities of potential employees and there is at least one test that would appear to be appropriate for testing Indigenous applicants.

Source: Professor G Kearney, c/- ValueEdge Management Consultants, http://www.valuedge.com.au/index.php

DRUG AND ALCOHOL TESTING

Drug and alcohol checks are very important throughout the industry due to the strong focus on setting high health and safety standards. Each of the sites in this study required applicants to undertake medical examinations and drug and alcohol testing. This procedure is the same for all applicants – Indigenous and non-Indigenous. Where the sites differed was in the way in which they responded to the test results. At some operations, failure to pass these mandatory testing regimes means that applicants are immediately rejected and informed that their application has been unsuccessful. Other sites, however, used test failure as an opportunity to provided feedback to applicants. The good practice sites took on an educative role, explaining to applicants why they had failed and giving them advice on how to get help for their medical problems. This took place during regular visits to communities.

They also advised applicants that they were able to reapply for positions at the site when their alcohol and other health problems were under control.

In some cases, the companies also provide drug testing kits to communities, so that Indigenous people can be tested prior to applying for a job to ensure they are clean. This process of continuous education has resulted in many people who originally tested positive for alcohol and drug use coming back and re-applying for work and being successful in gaining employment.

One mining operation also conducts security screening of all potential employees. This security check is similar to other good practice screening checks in that applicants are kept fully informed about what is happening and that they are not used to exclude employees from the operation on a permanent basis.

GOOD PRACTICE SCREENING CHECKS

Providing feedback

Many Indigenous applicants fail the standard medical examination and mandatory drug and alcohol testing. Company personnel with expertise in communicating with Indigenous people fulfil an important educative role when they provide feedback to applicants on why their application was unsuccessful.

Examples of good practice include:

The medical check

  • Øin the case of the health check, explaining what exactly is wrong and why it makes them unfit for work
  • Øexplaining what people can do in terms of lifestyle changes to improve their condition
  • Øadvising them to get further medical advice (if appropriate) and where to get it. ?Drug and alcohol testing
  • Øexplaining why they have failed the test
  • Ødirecting them to help for their drug or alcohol ?problem
  • Øinforming them how long it will take to ‘get clean’
  • Øadvising them that they can reapply for a position ?once they are confident they can pass the ?screening test
  • Øsupplying alcohol and drug testing kits to ?communities for self testing.

 

AMR Indigenous KC21288

CENTRE FOR SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY IN MINING

Phone: 61 (7) 3346 4003 Email: csrm@uq.edu.au

CSRM is a Member of the Sustainable Minerals Institute

www.csrm.uq.edu.au

 

ABOUT THE AUTHORS

Tony Tiplady, an experienced educator, trainer and mining operations manager, was seconded from Rio Tinto to the CSRM for 2 years to conduct this research project. He now works for Education Queensland.

Mary Anne Barclay is a Research Fellow at CSRM. Her research interests include workforce management issues, education and training, and corporate governance.

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment